Supernatural Nightmare (2005– ) Online
Sam has a premonition in which a man is killed, but the murder is made to look like a suicide. Sam convinces Dean that they must investigate the case, but the two are puzzled when they fail to find anything that indicates that the death was supernatural in nature. That is, until they find out that Max, the reclusive son of the first victim, has been using his recently acquired power of telekinesis to kill the family members that once abused him. Sam also discovers Max's mother was killed by the same fiery demon that took his own mom.
| Episode cast overview: | |||
 | Jared Padalecki | - | Sam Winchester |
 | Jensen Ackles | - | Dean Winchester |
 | Brendan Fletcher | - | Max Miller |
 | Beth Broderick | - | Alice Miller |
 | Fred Keating | - | Neighbor Man |
 | Avery Raskin | - | Roger Miller |
| Susinn McFarlen | - | Neighbor Lady |
 | Dalias Blake | - | Policeman |
| Cameron McDonald | - | Jim Miller |
Sam and Dean introduce themselves as Father Simmons and Father Frehley, the bassist and former lead guitarist of the rock band KISS.
Director Philip Sgriccia personally chose to use two early Bob Seger songs because he was from Michigan, and "Nightmare" took place in Saginaw. In addition to this, Sgriccia asked his sister to send him coffee mugs and baseball caps from Michigan to give believability to the setting.
Actress Beth Broderick is most famous for her role of Zelda Spellman, one of two Sabrina's unconventional witchy aunts, on a popular TV series Sabrina, the Teenage Witch (1996-2003) starring Melissa Joan Hart as Sabrina.
This episode confirms Sam's nascent psychic abilities. In fact, he meets a fellow sufferer, albeit one with more advanced powers.
Body count: 3
Dean and Sam discuss telekinesis and reference The Matrix when Dean says, "Oh, he's a spoon bender?".