The Barrel of a Gun (2010) Online

Tigre Hill viewed this incident, the cold blooded murder of a Philadelphia Police Officer, with a blind eye toward race. He gathers FACTS as well as the opinions of those blinded by the rhetoric and shows the obvious distinctions. Speaking with those present on the scene and still clearly affected by the events of that cold night, Tigre allows the viewer to form their own opinion but this viewer finds it impossible to come to any conclusion other than the one a jury and numerous appellate courts already have. There is no "acting" in this film. It is pure documentary with actual footage from the news vaults taken at the time of the crime and the trials. Interviews are conducted around the country and even the world gathering opinions of those who have been vocal in the matter and historical background about the studies of Wesley Cook (a.k.a. Mumia Abu Jamal) which may have influenced his actions on the night in question.

Due to IMDb's word count limitations I can only post an abridged version of my review. You can read my full review at http://r5- 4m.blogspot.com/2014/07/my-full-review-of-barrel-of-gun.html

Three viewings later I am still digesting the impact of this movie. It is brilliant on many levels. I want to give a thoughtful analysis though instead of just saying it is one of the best documentaries I've ever seen without explaining why.

On a purely technical film school level the production, narrative, and scene placement is excellent. The narrative flows very well. The soundtrack fits each scene perfectly and it doesn't overuse any music in a distracting way. There was absolutely not one second of the film that was boring. There was no pointless filler. As far as the running time it didn't feel too short or too long which is actually surprising because while watching it I really didn't want it to end. Its a little bit of a conundrum because it was like being presented a good meal with everything I would want. It wasn't missing anything and nothing was shorted. But it was just so good I wanted to come back for seconds.

The most important thing I can say about this documentary is that it deserves to exist. Many documentaries just rehash the basic facts without adding anything new to the documentary's subject matter. The Barrel of a Gun doesn't focus on rehashing the standard debating points about this case. It does go over the basic facts of the crime, as testified to in trial, but than shifts focus to providing a rich historical context to this case that has often been lost to those of us who didn't grow up in Philadelphia in the late 70's/early 80's. One doesn't need to come to this film with an in depth knowledge of the case to be able to understand the film.

Tigre Hill makes a solid case that Mumia's revolutionary activism, combined with his personal frustrations, led him to brutally murder Danny Faulkner. His research is intensive, his facts are sound and his journalistic integrity is flawless.

If one looks at the film objectively it becomes abundantly clear that Tigre Hill went out of his way to keep the film unbiased. Tigre interviewed subjects on both sides of the argument in a non confrontational way that allowed them to express their points of view. He didn't set anyone up to look foolish though a few ended up looking that way once they started talking.

Mumia's Supporters will try to argue that this film is dishonest and one sided because it doesn't indulge their imaginative perspectives on the facts of the case. This is extremely ironic because those words describe ALL of the Pro-Mumia documentaries. As it stands this film shows commentary from both sides equally while adhering strictly to proved facts. Unfortunately for Jamal the actual facts make it pretty clear that he is guilty.

Personally I think Tigre showed incredible restraint with some of his interviews. There were quite a few times that I wanted to smack some common sense into a few people's heads. There were a few questions that were left open-ended but that can only spark discussion which is a good thing.